Navigation Menu+

Kazakhstan Once

In the End Is the Beginning: Kazakhstan after Nazarbayev

The Khan Shatyr, the tent-shaped entertainment center in Kazakhstan’s capital, Astana. Ben Dalton/CRISIS GROUP/International Reporting ProjectKazakhstan has everything going for it: enormous natural resources from oil and gas to gold, uranium and rare earth metals; a young, multi-lingual population; and thousands of young foreign trained graduates, who return home every year under President Nursultan Nazarbayev’s Bolashak scholarship program.

But behind Nazarbayev’s strong leadership are weak institutions, a puppet parliament, fettered media and security services prone to excessive force, as demonstrated by the events in the oil town of Zhanaozen in 2011, when 16 striking oil workers were shot dead during protests on the nation’s Independence Day.

Nazarbayev, 73, who has ruled for more than 20 years, remains genuinely popular, but concerns about his health are now growing. Terrorism – once something that happened only to other Central Asian states – has blown aside the old sense of security. Jund al Khilafa, a group advocating a regional caliphate and sharia law, emerged in 2011 with a series of powerful attacks. Although this year has been quiet, the threat of Islamic extremism should not be underestimated, especially in the economically and socially deprived regions in the west of the country. Nazarbayev’s policy of economic progress first, political reforms second, has created large pockets of poverty and alienation.

Astana, Kazakhstan’s capital. Ben Dalton/CRISIS GROUP/International Reporting ProjectBeyond the main urban areas, unpaved roads lead to worn-out houses in neglected villages. Less than 60 kilometers from the futuristic skyscrapers of the capital, Astana (all built since 1997), some residents complain that the irregular water supply is not something the local authorities can be bothered to address. During the bitterly cold winters, heating in some Soviet-era apartment blocks is reportedly a hit-and-miss affair. The daily grind in such places is a world away from the 21st-century ambitions of Astana or the boulevards of Almaty, Kazakhstan’s other major city.

Although Nazarbayev tries to position his country as a bridge between Europe and the East, he still lives in a very rough neighborhood. Authoritarian to various degrees, violent and corrupt across the board, Central Asia’s nations face an uncertain future. Uzbekistan’s succession scenario – Islam Karimov, 75, has ruled since 1990 – is even more complicated that Kazakhstan’s; Kyrgyzstan limps from one political crisis to the next while Tajikistan continues to be run into the ground economically and politically by a venal ruling elite who border on the criminal.

Kazakhstan has always sought to position itself as a “land of democracy” in “the heart of Eurasia”. But in one crucial respect it is no different from many ex-Soviet states: the first phase of dismantling state power after the collapse of the Soviet Union was the reconcentration of wealth within the hands of a very small group of well-connected people who see little reason to share it. Most view any reform as a challenge to their well-being, which does not come cheap when the cost of a private jet and an upmarket address in London is factored in.

EricSmith Gerb Kazakhstan Coat Of Arms Flag Ussr Print Men O-neck Sweatshirts - Xx-large - Electric Grey
Sports (EricSmith)
  • Hanes 6.1oz beefy hoodies
  • Note!! please kindly send us message once you don t know the sizes.thank you!
  • High quality and fashioning shows in front of hoodies.
  • 100% satisfaction guarantee
  • Comfortable and soft to wear.
You might also like
Kazakhstan: President Nazarbayev awaits re-election
Kazakhstan: President Nazarbayev awaits re-election
Kazakhstan-Nazarbayev
Kazakhstan-Nazarbayev
KAZAKHSTAN: MADELEINE ALBRIGHT & PRESIDENT NAZARBAYEV
KAZAKHSTAN: MADELEINE ALBRIGHT & PRESIDENT NAZARBAYEV
Circle Kazakhstan (dd)++ Black Women Popular Hoodies Shirt Customized Medium
Apparel ()
  • Free to customize your own hoodies.
  • Note!! please kindly send us message once you don t know the sizes.thank you!
  • Machine wash,print and color won t fade after washing
  • Delivery time: 7-15 business days.
  • Circle Kazakhstan (dd)++ hoodiess
Add A Link Of Charm Kazakhstan Flag Italian Charm
Jewelry (Add A Link Of Charm)
  • Enamel Italian Charms are desired by many.
  • The design is formed, and then the chips are micro-lasered soldered to the stainless steel links.
  • You can design the bracelet all at once, or build the bracelet over time at your leisure.
  • They are 100% Stainless Steel which is great especially for folks who suffer from metal allergies
  • Going on a trip, or have you already been? Grab a flag to remember that great trip you had!
Apache Series Geranium 10 Seeds New Entry This Year Early Bloom Compact Growth
Lawn & Patio ()
  • Apache F1 Series Geranium Pelargonium x hortorum
  • Geranium Apache is early flowering and its branching is extremely basal. Apache is vigorous yet compact in growth and develops a profusion of large flowers on compact...
  • 10 SEEDS PER PACKAGE
  • GERANIUM Planting Instructions Start inside at least 12 weeks before last spring frost. Cover seed lightly and then provide constant warmth; 70-75°F and moisture...
  • Excludes ship to: Africa, South America, Brunei Darussalam, Cambodia, Indonesia, Laos, Macau, Taiwan, Vietnam, Afghanistan, Armenia, Azerbaijan Republic, Bangladesh...
BradfoHod Bradfohod Men Kazakhstan Printed T-shirt (medium,green)
Apparel (BradfoHod)
  • Material: cotton
  • Note!! please kindly send us message once you don t know the sizes.thank you!
  • Short sleeve
  • Machine wash,no shrinking.
  • Made of high quality cotton
Related Posts